Salary Negotiation Email Templates: Counter Offers, Scripts & Data (2025)

Landing an offer is exciting. Accepting one that undervalues your contribution isn’t. Recruiters expect you to negotiate, but most candidates freeze because they don’t know what to say, when to send it, or how to back requests with data.

This guide gives you a negotiation operating system: a prep checklist, timeline, compensation research toolkit, and copy-and-paste email templates for every scenario. Pair it with JobPilot’s application tracker so every offer, counter, and benefit tradeoff stays organized in one place.

Before you send anything: negotiation prep checklist

You’ll negotiate better if you treat it like a project with inputs and outputs. Complete this checklist while you’re interviewing so you’re ready the second an offer hits your inbox.

1. Define your walk-away number. Calculate your monthly baseline costs + savings targets + opportunity cost. This becomes your bottom line.
2. Research market data. Collect at least three sources (Levels.fyi, Glassdoor, recruiter intel) for your role, location, and level.
3. Rank your priorities. Salary, bonus, equity, PTO, remote flexibility, titles—know what matters most.
4. Document unique value. Highlight metrics and differentiators you can reference during negotiation.
5. Log everything in JobPilot. Track offer details, deadlines, and recruiter notes so you don’t mix up numbers across opportunities.

Pro tip: Start a “Comp Benchmarks” note inside JobPilot or your tracker spreadsheet. Copy salary snapshots for each company and update as you progress through interviews.

---

Salary negotiation timeline

Stage	What happens	Your action
Offer received	Recruiter emails or calls with salary/benefits	Thank them, request offer letter, ask for time to review
Discovery window (24–48 hrs)	You review comp details, benefits, leveling	Research market data, align expectations, craft counter
Counter offer sent	Email with specific salary/benefit ask	Provide data, highlight value, request call if needed
Negotiation loop	Recruiter responds with revised numbers or constraints	Stay collaborative, negotiate 1–2 variables at a time
Final decision	Company gives best offer or holds firm	Accept, request final paperwork, or decline professionally

Use JobPilot’s reminder system (or the Job Application Tracker Template) to set deadlines for each stage so no recruiter needs to chase you.

---

Template library: proven negotiation emails

Customize these scripts to match your tone and compensation data.

1. Initial counter (base salary focus)

Subject: Offer for [Role Name]

Hi [Recruiter Name],

Thank you for the offer—I'm excited about the opportunity to join [Company] and partner with the [Team Name] on [project/problem].

After reviewing the details and current market data for Senior [Role] roles in [Location], I'm targeting a base salary of [$X]. This aligns with the impact we discussed (scaling [metric], leading [initiative], etc.) and the compensation ranges I’m seeing from Levels.fyi and recent offers.

If we can align around [$X] base plus the existing bonus/equity structure, I’m confident we can wrap everything up quickly. Happy to jump on a call to walk through it.

Thanks again,
[Your Name]

2. Counter focused on total comp (base + equity/bonus)

Subject: Offer details

Hi [Recruiter Name],

I appreciate the clarity on the offer. The role itself is a strong fit. To make the total compensation work, I’d love to discuss two adjustments:

1. Base salary closer to [$X] (market midpoint for Staff-level roles in [Location])
2. Refresh equity to [$Y] to match the scope of leading [initiative]

If there’s flexibility on either lever, I’m ready to sign quickly. Let me know if a quick call is easier.

Best,
[Your Name]

3. Remote or hybrid flexibility request

Subject: Offer question

Hi [Recruiter Name],

Thank you for the offer package. One item I wanted to confirm is workplace flexibility. To perform at my best, I’d like to work remotely at least [number] days per week. My recent track record leading [project] was fully remote, and I can share references on how I collaborate asynchronously.

If we can agree on a [remote/hybrid] arrangement plus the current compensation details, I’m fully on board. Let me know your thoughts.

Thank you,
[Your Name]

4. Multiple offers leverage (keep it respectful)

Subject: Timeline + offer alignment

Hi [Recruiter Name],

I wanted to share that I’m in final discussions with another team that’s targeting a total package of [$X] base / [$Y] equity. [Company] remains my top choice because of [reason].

If you’re able to bring the base salary closer to [$X] (or adjust the equity grant), I’d be comfortable moving forward with [Company] today. I realize budgets exist, so I appreciate any flexibility you can explore.

Happy to chat live if helpful.

Best,
[Your Name]

5. Internal promotion or raise request

Subject: Compensation review

Hi [Manager Name],

Over the last 12 months, I’ve [quantifiable achievements]. Based on our current scope and market data for [role/level] in [location], the fair market range is [$X–$Y]. I’d like to discuss aligning my compensation with this range and formalizing a [title] promotion.

Can we set up 30 minutes this week to walk through the data? I’m happy to prepare a detailed summary for finance/HR.

Thanks for the continued support,
[Your Name]

6. Declining due to compensation (future relationship intact)

Subject: Offer decision

Hi [Recruiter Name],

Thank you for the generous offer and all the time the team invested in the interviews. After careful consideration, I’ve decided to pursue another opportunity that’s closer to my target compensation range of [$X].

I genuinely enjoyed meeting everyone and hope we can reconnect if circumstances change. Please keep me in mind for future roles—I’d happily recommend other candidates in my network as well.

Warmly,
[Your Name]

---

Building the perfect counter number

Don’t pick numbers randomly. Use this stack to defend every request.

Source	Use it for	Example
Levels.fyi	Base, stock, bonus benchmarks by level	“Median Staff PM comp in NYC: $210K base + $70K equity”
OpenComp / Ravio	Startup salary ranges	“Series B SaaS VP Marketing midpoint: $190K”
Blind/TeamBlind	Anonymous crowd data	Validate equity refresh cadence
Company filings	Public comp bands (for CA/NY job posts)	“Job listing states $140K–$180K salary band”
Recruiter intel	Current budgets and constraints	“Team has two salary bands depending on years of experience”

Formula for determining your counter

1. Calculate market midpoint (average of 3–5 data points).
2. Add 10–15% premium for unique skills (niche tech, leadership, languages).
3. Subtract 5–10% if you need the role urgently (visa timelines, unemployment).
4. Round to a clean number ending in 0 or 5.

Example:
Midpoint = $170K → +10% premium for Workday automation expertise ($187K) → round to $190K base ask.

---

Negotiation best practices

1. Stay collaborative. Frame every ask as solving a shared challenge (“to ensure I can focus fully on this work…”).
2. Negotiate multiple levers. Salary, equity, signing bonus, remote flexibility, title, PTO, education budget.
3. Avoid ultimatums. Present data and genuine enthusiasm instead of “raise it or I walk.”
4. Know when to stop. Two well-reasoned counter rounds are plenty.
5. Get everything in writing. Once you agree verbally, request updated letter before signing.
6. Log each step. Track recruiter name, numbers, and promises in JobPilot or your tracker template.

---

Using JobPilot to manage compensation conversations

Job searches involve dozens of moving parts. JobPilot centralizes them:

• Offer tracking: Every application autofilled via the JobPilot Chrome extension automatically captures salary bands and recruiter contacts in your Career Dashboard.
• Notes & documents: Attach offer letters, equity calculators, and negotiation notes to each opportunity card.
• Reminders: Set reminders for counter deadlines, recruiter calls, and paperwork.
• Analytics: Compare compensation across companies to see which industries value you most.
• CTA placement: Turn your negotiation win into a case study by logging the outcome for future reference.

If you prefer spreadsheets, duplicate our Job Application Tracker Template and add columns for base, bonus, equity, benefits, and final decision.

---

Mistakes to avoid

1. Countering before seeing paperwork. Always request the full written offer.
2. Sharing your current salary. In many regions it’s illegal for employers to ask—redirect to your expectations.
3. Negotiating via text. Keep it to email/phone/video. Slack/DMs get lost.
4. Over-explaining personal expenses. Focus on market data and business impact.
5. Accepting under pressure. A recruiter asking for an answer “Tonight” is a tactic. Ask for 24 hours.
6. Forgetting benefits. If base is locked, negotiate PTO, professional development, relocation, or flexible start dates.

---

FAQs

Can I negotiate if the salary range was posted?
Yes. Ranges show minimums and maximums. If you’re at the top of the band, negotiate for signing bonus, equity, accelerated review, or remote flexibility.

Is it better to negotiate live or via email?
Email creates a documented trail and lets you craft thoughtful wording. Complex packages often benefit from a short call followed by written confirmation.

What if the recruiter refuses to budge?
Ask what constraints exist. If comp truly can’t move, decide whether other benefits make the role worthwhile. If not, decline politely and keep the relationship warm.

Should I mention competing offers?
Yes—if they’re real. Be transparent about timelines and numbers without revealing company names unless necessary.

How fast should I respond?
Aim to acknowledge the offer same day and send your counter within 48 hours. Longer delays signal disinterest.

---

Negotiation is simply advocating for the value you already demonstrated during interviews. Use data to justify your ask, lean on these templates for clarity, and keep the process organized inside JobPilot so every offer turns into a strategic decision—not a rushed yes.